By Marikita Saure
The Odd Couple, Community Players, Sunday September 7, 2025
Neil Simon’s The Odd Couple remains a comedy classic, and Community Players’ current production in Beatrice proves why. Whether you know it from the original play, the film, or the long-running TV series, this mismatched-roommate story still packs plenty of laughs. Fate (and perhaps bad luck) throws Oscar Madison and Felix Unger together as roommates after both find themselves newly and nearly divorced, and the result is a crash course in chaos. When polar opposites share one eight bedroom apartment, hilarity—and mayhem—are bound to follow.
One of the show’s greatest strengths lies in its design. Natalia Kraviec’s set, with props and dressing by Jean Spilker and Jim Beran, is a feast for the eyes. Stepping back into the 1960s, the stage feels like a lived-in New York apartment—half sitcom set, half bachelor pad in disarray. With the creative dimension the set provides, you truly feel like you’re sardined into the action. Scattered cans, bottles, clothes, and trinkets perfectly capture Oscar’s signature mess. Jenny Sutphin’s costume design completes the picture, from sharp period details to the Pigeon sisters’ chic ensembles. (Though I did find Oscar’s attire a touch too tidy- especially at the start of the show- for a man of his slovenly reputation).
The heart of the play, of course, is the odd couple themselves. Mason Gustafson’s Oscar exudes an easygoing, unbothered charm, while Brandon Clark’s Felix is all precision and neurosis. Together, they create a magnetic push-and-pull, selling both the affection and exasperation that define their friendship. Their chemistry makes even the smallest domestic squabble feel like an epic clash of wills. Both actors’ acting chops really shine when they easily achieve chuckles throughout the audience with little to few words in a hilarious scene nearer to the end.
The production really soars in Act II with the arrival of the Pigeon sisters, played with delightful spark by Ashley Hothan as Gwendolyn Pidgeon and Marissa Saure as Cecily Pidgeon respectively. Their playful energy and effortless comedic timing elevate the scenes, turning Oscar and Felix’s ill-fated dinner date into one of the evening’s highlights.
If there’s one area where the production falters, it’s in pacing during a few scenes. At times, the dialogue felt either a little underrehearsed—actors unintentionally stepping on each other’s lines—or slowed, leaving some exchanges less punchy than Simon’s script demands. Comedy thrives on rhythm, and with a little more attention to timing, the already-strong performances could land with even greater impact.
Still, the show delivers on what audiences come for: quick wit, physical comedy, and a story with heart. The Odd Couple at Community Players is a charming reminder that even in the messiest of situations, laughter wins out. Grab a ticket—you’ll be glad you did.
If you go (and you should!)
Community Players
412 Ella Street
Beatrice, NE 68310
Remaining show dates: September 12-14
Tickets can be purchased online at beatricecommunityplayers.com, by calling the box office at (402)228-1801, or in person at the box office.
Marikita Saure is a passionate supporter and participant of the performing arts, appearing as an actress, artist, and director for shows in Lincoln and the surrounding areas. She is a big animal lover and has two dogs (Saint Bernard and Terrier mix) whom she loves dearly.
As always, if you liked this content and want more, please join our email list and like us on Facebook!